"Seriously Underwater" Home Mortgages Tick Up Across the US
Peachtree CEO Greg Friedman comments on a recent article by Alexandre Tanzi for Bloomberg about the state of the multifamily market in the US.
Special Situations Investing: Why Now Is the Time to Act in Commercial Real Estate
Listen to Our Podcast!
In the latest Peachtree Point of View podcast episode, Daniel Savage, SVP of Investment & Strategy at Peachtree Group moderates a discussion with Peachtree CEO Greg Friedman and Executive Vice President of Investments Michael Ritz as they explore how the commercial real estate landscape has fundamentally shifted, creating unprecedented opportunities for special situations investing. The executives present a compelling case for deploying capital into special situations strategies—but the window won't remain open indefinitely.
The Market Reality: Strong Assets, Broken Capital Structures
Unlike previous cycles where distress stemmed from fundamental asset problems, today's opportunities are primarily driven by capital market volatility. As Michael Ritz explains: "Fundamentals generally across most commercial real estate assets outside of office are doing pretty well. But what we're seeing is just the heightened level of volatility" in capital markets.
This creates a unique environment where high-quality assets are trading at discounted valuations not because of operational issues, but due to financing constraints and capital structure challenges.
The Debt Market Disruption
The core driver of today's opportunity lies in the dramatic repricing of debt. With the Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR) rising from near-zero levels during the pandemic to current elevated rates, traditional financing has both become more expensive. Banks are now underwriting to lower loan-to-value ratios while demanding higher debt service coverage ratios, creating significant gaps incapital stacks.
Consider this: a simple cap rate expansion from 8% to 9% can reduce a $100 million asset's value to $89 million overnight. When combined with reduced loan-to-values, property owners face substantial liquidity shortfalls that create entry points for special situations investors.
Three Key Investment Buckets
Investors should focus on three primary opportunity areas:
- Off-market acquisitions: Securing underperforming or mispriced hotels as well as select multifamily, student housing, self-storage and other commercial real estate sectors for repositioning and stabilization.
- Preferred and hybrid equity solutions: Providing flexible capital to sponsors needing liquidity for acquisitions, development or refinancing with structures designed to protect basis and enhance current yields.
- Distressed purchases from lenders: Acquiring assets directly from banks through deed-in-lieu or post-foreclosure transactions, often at discounts to outstanding loan balances and well below replacement cost.
The Hospitality Sweet Spot
Hotels present particularly compelling opportunities, with outsized exposure to near-term debt maturities due to years of "extend and pretend" financing. The sector faces approximately $15-20 billion in deferred capital expenditures, coinciding with assets built during the 2008 supply surge now requiring their typical 14-year renovation cycle.
Why Traditional Players Can't Compete
The opportunity exists precisely because few firms can provide the hybrid solutions these situations demand. Success requires capabilities across both equity and credit, enabling structured investments such as junior debt with contingent repayment ("hopenotes"), preferred equity positions, or debt-to-own strategies.
Why Special Situation Investing Works Now
For investors evaluating special situation investing opportunities, the key is partnering with operators who possess both the capital flexibility and operational expertise to navigate complex deal structures. The current environment rewards those who can move quickly on opportunities that traditional lenders and equity providers cannot address.
As Greg Friedman notes, this represents the biggest mispriced risk opportunity in commercial real estate today. The question for investors isn't whether these opportunities exist; it's whether they're positioned to capitalize on them before the market corrects.
For a deeper dive into the market dynamics and investment strategies discussed here, listen to the full conversation on the Peachtree Point of View podcast. The episode provides additional insights into how investors can navigate today's special situations landscape and position themselves for outsized returns in this unique market environment.
THIS IS NOT AN OFFER OR SOLICITATION TO PURCHASE ANY SECURITY. AN OFFERING IS MADE ONLY BY THE PRIVATE PLACEMENT MEMORANDUM. SECURITIES OFFERED THROUGH PEACHTREE PC INVESTORS, LLC MEMBER FINRA/SIPC.
Related posts
If you enjoyed this article, read through these related press releases and insights.
It seems like the housing market is currently in a better position compared to previous economic recessions, such as the one in 2009. Back then, 26% of mortgaged residential properties had negative equity, while now it's only about 2.7%. Although industries reliant on debt, like commercial real estate, are facing challenges recalibrating to higher interest rates, it's unlikely that we're headed towards a major economic recession without a significant setback in the housing market.
The stability of the housing sector can help cushion against economic downturns, as it directly impacts consumer wealth and confidence, which in turn influences spending - a significant factor considering that consumer expenditures make up about 70% of the U.S. GDP. This stability enhances the likelihood of sustained economic growth rather than a descent into a recession.
This commentary originally appeared on Greg Friedman's LinkedIn page on May 15, 2024, in response to a Bloomberg article by Alexandre Tanzi titled: "Seriously Underwater' Home Mortgages Tick Up Across the US.
Follow Greg Friedman and Peachtree Group on LinkedIn.
Learn more about Peachtree Group's Credit division.
A Critical Recessioin Red Flag is Missing
Peachtree CEO Greg Friedman comments on a recent article by Phil Rosen for Inc. Magazine that examines loan demand despite high interest rates.
Prior to 2022, borrowers enjoyed for over a decade the opportunity to secure loans at near-zero interest rates, a boon that fueled growth and expansion in the commercial real estate market. Today, we see an unprecedented volume of loans maturing in a much higher interest rate environment, with banks reducing exposure to commercial real estate. Despite these conditions, the demand for loans continues to grow.
Historically, a spike in loan demand during higher interest rates would be a warning sign of a looming credit crunch. Yet, defying expectations, recent data suggests a deviation from this pattern, with banks reporting increased lending activity despite maintaining onerous lending standards. This anomaly, combined with moderated inflation, challenges traditional recession indicators. While some analysts cautiously suggest that "this time is different," economic uncertainties persist, posing an interesting question about the underlying market dynamics.
While uncertainties linger, one thing remains clear: the commercial real estate sector faces a pivotal juncture. We are navigating the evolving landscape vigilantly, balancing risk and opportunity in a market shaped by unprecedented forces.
This commentary originally appeared on Greg Friedman's LinkedIn page on May 16, 2024, in response to an Inc magazine article by Phil Rosen titled: A Critical Recession Red Flag is Missing.
Follow Greg Friedman and Peachtree Group on LinkedIn.
Learn more about Peachtree Group's Credit division.
Watch for These Signs of Recession as the Fed Keeps Rates Elevated
Peachtree CEO Greg Friedman comments on a recent article by Richard Berger for Globestreet. The article is a response to the Federal Reserve keeping interest rates steady.
The CPI report earlier this week showed a decrease in U.S. inflation pressures for the first time this year, following a higher-than-anticipated PPI. This might suggest the Fed's sustained efforts to mitigate consumer price pressures are beginning to show results. However, we are still far from reaching 2%, but maybe the Fed is seeing that inflation is finally on a downward trajectory. In my opinion, the Fed will need further data to gather the confidence required for contemplating interest rate cuts.
Today's prolonged high interest rates are dampening activity and risking recession. For the commercial real estate industry, time is of the essence, as we are already in a recession, and I am dimming on the prospect of a rate cut this year.
This persistent inflation significantly challenges the commercial real estate sector, especially with trillions of dollars of debt maturing. Elevated inflation has increased borrowing costs, strained cash flows and impacted property valuations.
Property owners face refinancing at significantly higher rates as debt matures, leading to increased debt service costs and reduced profitability. This strain on cash flows, coupled with higher expenses and lower income, creates a vicious cycle. Property valuations decline as borrowing costs rise, and investors demand higher returns, softening the market. This downward spiral tightens financial constraints, risking defaults and market instability, a situation that requires immediate attention.
Can the Fed get us out of this spiral before a larger meltdown without triggering new economic challenges?
The path forward will likely require a mix of monetary policy adjustments based on economic data and perhaps more targeted fiscal interventions to support vulnerable sectors.
No matter where the market leads, I'm enthusiastic about the opportunities that lie ahead, and our team is fully prepared to tackle the challenges.
This commentary originally appeared on Greg Friedman's LinkedIn page on May 19, 2024, in response to a Globestreet article titled: Watch for These Signs of Recession as the Fed Keeps Rates Elevated.
Follow Greg Friedman and Peachtree Group on LinkedIn